Manchester City coach criticizes focus on controversial Haaland goal

Manchester City beat Manchester United 1-0 in the September 13 derby, and instead of celebrating a gritty win with ten men, coach Enzo Maresca spent his post-match press conference telling reporters they were asking the wrong questions.

Erling Haaland’s 60th-minute strike, initially ruled out for offside before being awarded after a VAR review, has become the most dissected goal of the young Premier League season. Maresca’s position is simple: it was a good goal, move on.

What actually happened on the pitch

Phil Foden received a red card in the 23rd minute, leaving City to play more than 70 minutes a man down against their crosstown rivals.

Haaland’s goal in the 60th minute was initially chalked off for offside. The linesman’s flag went up, the United fans exhaled, and the moment appeared dead. But VAR intervened, reviewing the play and determining that United defender Patrick Dorgu had played Haaland onside.

The issue centered on City midfielder Enzo Fernandez, who was standing in an offside position during the buildup. The question was whether Fernandez interfered with play, which would have invalidated the goal regardless of Haaland’s positioning. VAR concluded he did not.

The Professional Game Match Officials Limited, the body responsible for Premier League referees, later acknowledged an “error of judgement” regarding the potential interference from Fernandez.

Maresca’s pointed response

At the post-match press conference, Maresca made clear he thought the media’s fixation on the refereeing decision was, in his words, poor. Rather than relitigating every camera angle, the City boss wanted to talk about what his squad had just accomplished: winning a derby with ten men, extending their perfect start to the season.

His argument had a certain logic to it. The fourth official had confirmed Haaland was onside even before the VAR review began, suggesting the initial disallowance was itself the mistake. In Maresca’s framing, VAR corrected an error rather than creating one.

The win pushed City to four victories from four matches under Maresca. Haaland has now scored nine goals in Premier League derbies alone.

The VAR debate that won’t die

The PGMOL’s admission of an error of judgement is notable because it rarely happens. Publicly conceding a mistake while the result remains unchanged creates an awkward middle ground. City keep the three points, United’s grievance gets validated on paper, and nothing actually changes.

The PGMOL’s admission does raise a legitimate question about consistency going forward. If officials acknowledge the Fernandez offside position warranted different treatment, clubs will expect that standard to be applied in future matches.

For Maresca, the calculation is straightforward. His team won a match they had every reason to lose after going down to ten men in the first half hour. The goal was reviewed by technology designed to get these calls right, and it was awarded.

Disclosure: This article was edited by Editorial Team. For more information on how we create and review content, see our Editorial Policy.