1 hour ago
16
Crystal Palace and Everton are in active discussions over a potential player swap that would see winger Dwight McNeil head to Selhurst Park while Brennan Johnson moves to Goodison Park. The talks, first reported by journalist Alan Nixon, represent a creative solution for two clubs trying to solve different problems with the same transaction.
What’s on the table
The proposed swap would involve McNeil, 26, a left winger who has been a consistent performer for Everton, heading south to Crystal Palace. Going the other direction would be Johnson, 25, a right winger who Palace signed from Tottenham in January 2026 for a club-record fee of roughly £35 million.
That’s a significant gap in recent transfer valuations. Johnson cost Palace nearly double what McNeil’s standalone deal was worth when the clubs last negotiated, which means any swap would likely require additional structuring to bridge the difference.
A January deal gone wrong
During the January 2026 transfer window, Crystal Palace agreed to a £20 million fee for McNeil. The winger traveled, completed his medical examinations, and by all accounts was ready to become a Palace player. Then, on the final day of the window, the deal collapsed. The fallout was public and messy, drawing criticism from multiple directions. For McNeil, it meant returning to Everton after mentally preparing for a fresh start. For Palace, it meant scrambling for alternatives and ultimately pivoting to the more expensive Johnson signing from Spurs.
Johnson’s time at Selhurst Park hasn’t exactly gone to script. Despite the hefty price tag, he has struggled to lock down consistent playing time and deliver the kind of performances that justify a club-record outlay.
Why this makes sense for both clubs
For Crystal Palace, McNeil represents unfinished business. The club clearly rated him enough to agree a £20 million deal, and that interest hasn’t cooled. Under new manager Pierre Sage, Palace are reportedly building toward a potential Europa League campaign, which could serve as a significant carrot in convincing McNeil that south London is the right destination.
For Everton, manager David Moyes is reportedly viewing McNeil as a key bargaining chip to land Johnson, whose age profile and versatility on the right flank could offer something different to Everton’s attacking options. Johnson’s contract extends for several more years, giving Everton long-term security on the asset if they can negotiate favorable terms.
The contract lengths are worth watching closely. McNeil’s deal with Everton is shorter than Johnson’s Palace contract, which creates an inherent valuation asymmetry. A player with fewer years remaining is worth less on paper, regardless of on-pitch ability. That disparity will need to be addressed, whether through a cash adjustment, performance-based add-ons, or some other mechanism.
What to watch
The January collapse adds a complication. McNeil has already been burned once by a Palace move that didn’t materialize. Whether he’s willing to go through the process again, particularly after the public nature of the last failure, is a genuine question that won’t be answered in a boardroom.
If the deal does get done, it would represent one of the more significant player exchanges in recent Premier League history, both in terms of the combined valuations involved and the narrative complexity surrounding the two players. For now, though, it remains a discussion rather than a done deal, and anyone who followed the January saga knows that’s a distinction worth respecting.
Disclosure: This article was edited by Editorial Team. For more information on how we create and review content, see our Editorial Policy.
English (US) ·